Very odd. Problem persists:
Did a drive image restore
Reinstalled WindowBlinds
Applied permissions in ESET
Rebooted
Applied Alluminate theme (no change on start menu)
Rebooted (no change on start menu)
Could it be a permissions problem somewhere?
Also, though doubt it matters, but I do have C:\User and C:\ProgramData directed to another drive.
(I did do a drive image restore on each of the drives)