I don't understand RASTLIN why you would go and post in a thread about a show you don't watch. I mean do you just like enflamming people? There is several thousand other threads on this board. If you cannot contribute to this thread, pelase exercise some etiquette and leave.

I think you should definitely try to watch one episode of SGU, just to let us now, what you think about it....maybe in the end you will agree with us, it is not good enough, even if our opinions about SG-1 do not match. I agree with you that BSG is deeper and probably better show than any of SG (though i think i like them both equally), but Universe while it tries  to be like BSG, it is nowhere near it. But it sucks for different reasons than you say SG-1 sucked, not because it is like SG-1.

Still to be fair i am still watching it, cause i still have faith and do not want to write it off just after few episodes. IMO BSG´s first season until the last episode was not extra spectacular as well, same goes, for B5, DS9 and other shows...what i have seen  actually only Andromeda and Earth Final Conflict started great, but than faded.

Anyway you lot seem to adore the Firefly, i have not seen yet. Is it really that good and worth of getting? I confess the name of Joss Whedon does not excite me, cause i suppose he made Buffy right? And i did not like that very much (except Sarah Michelle Gellar, she rocked hehe), though i probably did not seen enough to judge it.

sounding a little butthurt there bro.

um, im not bulling anyone lol.

and pulling out the 'build a bridge a get over it' card is no better. Raistlin has the opportunity to say: i dont like SG1, and he has the opportunity to clarify it further if he wishes. however, he didnt, he came in with his flamebat a-burning looking for a fight, and trying to justify his position with a greater-than-thou because i watch 'deep sci-fi' attitude which would gain him no brownie points even with people who potentially agree with him.

coming in here and saying: 'Stargate is dumb' and and variants and 'sounding a little butthurt there bro' is proof of his maturity level. and honestly, that such blunt comments can come from someone who supposedly appreciates 'deep' entertainment, makes me doubt the value of said shows.

lastly, attacking someone who is expressing distress over an opinion is bullying. plain and simple. im not only talking about Raistlin, im talking about Star Adder. its like saying, right, well, you dont like the fact this guy is using offensive analogies and turn of phrase to describe his dislike of X, but, you arent allowed to say anything because of freedom of speech [/oxymoron]

Raistlin can have his opinon. there are appropriate ways to voice his opinion. doing so in such a fashion that is offensive is not one of them. he said himself, he came flying in when someone 'badmouthed' DS9 or whatever. so he didnt appreciate it, what gives him the right to dish it right back out?

No one said "im going to report you to the mods" I warned that further flaming may get him reported.
Now the two of you want to talk about "running to mommy like children" your the ones continueing to act childish when your warned. Running around name calling and trying to insunate that somoene is running to their mommy is as childish as playing with blocks. Is that what you and raist do when you dont get your way? you harrass someone til they accept your bad behavior? Maybe you and Raist are used to getting your way with others. But that doesnt fly with me. So you want me to "threaten" to report. Ill do one better. The next person decides to flame i PROMISE to press that report button.

haha, that made me laugh =P

s g u  is  boring and  flat,   if  bsg  have a new temp  all pleople  forget sgu

Tonights episode was a step better then the last what 7 episodes, might of been because there wasnt much arguing this time around. And the crew was actually getting into it with alien chest suckers.

Moose, I hate to brak it to you, but a lot of America is brain-dead.

I just assumed that the Retelling of a retelling would have been too much and so they just made it seem like until they were able to save themselves theyd be stuck in the loop. So its assumed that Scotts last message about what to look for and what to expect forced them to rally faster then the last time.

The first time they watched the recording of the kino it recorded EVERYTHING that happened on the planet...almost 36 hours worth. This time it only had to record an hour or so.

The Crew has plenty of time this time around to save themselves. And its reflected in the next episode that picks up outside the loop. While I would have liked to see them actually  save themselves its safe to assume they actually did save themselves this time.

The venomious alien creatures could be chopped up to conicidence that they get sick just as they arrive at this planet where a venom is capable of killing off the bacteria they have been drinking.

Think about it their going planet to planet. Eventually they would have ran into some vicious creatures. The venom just happened to be able to attack the bacteria. There was no link. But at the same time they had to explain where the bacteria came from, as well how to deal with the alien creatures.

Im not going to harp on this episode because for me its a step in the right direction. I want to see more episodes where they get it in with the enemy. But I know for a fact they dont have that much ammo so sooner or later the writers are going to have to link them back to earth. Maybe via a beam device that you see on the Asgard ships.

"With two failed time lines it looks like it could simply loop  forever, unless in one they could manage to come up with a way of getting a creature back to Destiny without everyone dying first."

lol, that just gave me the most awesome story line every for the series:

Season 1: or, How We got a Disease and got stuck in a Time Loop.

Season 2: or, Capturing a Creature.

Season 3: or, How We got out of the Time loop.

And of course since they are in a time loop, they can stay there as long as they want.

But seriously... time loop plots are probably my least favorite of all. They feel like playing a video game with cheat codes enabled... you can do whatever you want, and screw up anything you want, and there are no consequences. I think the only time travel episode I liked was "1969" in season 1. For the most part, they end up being one of two varieties, A: cheat codes enabled or B: we just showed you an episode which resolves in nothing happening to effect the main plot line(such as "2010" or the Continuum movie). IMO, the only way to make time loop episodes good is to load them with so much humor you ignore the fact that the story of them really wasn't that great.